About

Forsythe Insurance Services

Marco Island's Trusted Insurance Partner for Home, Auto, and Beyond

When you’ve chosen to call Marco Island home, protecting your coastal lifestyle and long-term investments becomes essential. Forsythe Insurance Services has been a trusted part of the community, known for reliability, local expertise, and a genuine commitment to those we serve. As a locally rooted, family-oriented agency, we understand the unique aspects of living on a barrier island and the value of guidance you can depend on.


Founded on experience and attention to detail, our team prioritizes clear communication, thoughtful planning, and personalized support. We take pride in offering straightforward guidance, ensuring every client feels confident in their decisions. By listening first and tailoring recommendations to individual needs and long-term goals, we help simplify what can often feel complex.


What sets Forsythe Insurance Services apart is our dedication to strong client relationships and community trust. We strive to be responsive, accessible, and dependable, providing ongoing support and transparent communication every step of the way. With a focus on integrity and professionalism, we aim to give every client peace of mind through trusted guidance and personalized care. Contact us today to learn more about how Forsythe Insurance Services can support your needs with trusted guidance and personalized care.

Smiling driver holding car keys out the open window of a blue car

About

Forsythe Insurance Services' owner Robert has 26 years of experience in the insurance industry. He was born and raised right here in Naples, FL and knows exactly what the local residents and businesses need when it comes to insurance coverage. Additionally, Robert prides himself on being an advocate for you and your insurance needs.

Year Established

2011

Products

  • Homeowners Insurance
  • Automotive Insurance
  • Business Insurance
  • Personal Article Insurance
  • Motorcycles Insurance
  • ATVs Insurance
  • Boats Insurance
  • RVs Insurance
  • Flood Insurance
  • Wind and Hurricane Insurance

Services

  • Liability Coverage
  • Car Insurance Discounts
  • Insurance Services
  • Insurance Policy

Specialties

  • Home Insurance
  • Condo Insurance
  • Auto Insurance
  • Umbrella Insurance
  • Boat Insurance

Associations

  • FAIA (Florida Association of Independent Agents)
  • Trusted Choice
  • Voted Best Insurance Agency in Marco Island for 2026
  • Best of 2026 Award Winner by Business Rate

Brands

  • ASI/Progressive
  • Chubb
  • Cypris
  • Edison
  • Florida Family
  • Florida Peninsula
  • Monarch National
  • Orchid
  • Progressive
  • Sage Sure
  • Ski Safe
  • Travelers
  • Universal Property

Pickup and Delivery

Payment Options

  • American Express
  • Cash
  • Check
  • Discover
  • MasterCard
  • Visa

  • Automatic Bank Withdrawal

Languages

  • English


Good to Know

Service options

  • Online appointments